TARP: Troubled Asset Relief Program or Wall Street Feeding Frenzy?

Posted on November 19th, 2008 by PerotCharts

The Emergency Economic Stabilization Act (more commonly known as the Wall Street Bailout Plan) was passed under the presumption that $700B was needed to buy up troubled assets such as mortgage backed securities (which is why the program was originally called TARP - for Troubled Asset Relief Program). The program was supposed to work by taking the troubled assets off the market and off bank balance sheets thereby enabling the banks to regain their footing and not be forced to sell these assets at fire sale prices.  The plan was supposed to stop the downward price spiral of mortgage related securities, free up capital for loans, slow foreclosures and stabilize the financial markets.  That was the plan anyway…

But the act placed very few restrictions on how the money could be used. So its not surprising that the use of the funds changed from purchasing troubled assets to direct injection of capital (taxpayer provided) into a handful of financial institutions who promised to make those funds available for loans. It now appears that some of those institutions have chosen to pay bonuses and dividends that they would not otherwise been able to afford without the injection of government funds.

Representative Henry Waxman (D. - California), Chairman of the House Committee on Government Oversight and Reform, sent this letter to Mr. Vikram Pandit, CEO of CitiBank. in which the Chairman observes:

Earlier this month, the Treasury Department announced plans to invest $125 billion of
taxpayer funds in nine major banks, including yours, as an emergency measure to rebuild
depleted capital. According to recent public filings, these nine banks have spent or reserved
$108 billion for employee compensation and bonuses in the first nine months of 2008, nearly the same amount as last year.

Some experts have suggested that a significant percentage of this compensation could
come in year-end bonuses and that the size of the bonuses will be significantly enhanced as a
result of the infusion of taxpayer funds. According to one analyst, “Had it not been for the
government’s help in refinancing their debt they may not have had the cash to pay bonuses.”

Chairman Waxman states that his committee will be investigating these claims and requested information from CitiBank.

For reference, the financial institutions which received TARP cash injections are listed below. The rest of the approximately $350M which has been spent so far under the program was used to shore up AIG (in the form of loans and purchase of troubled assets).

CAPITAL PURCHASE PROGRAM Transaction Report

Updated on November 17, 2008; 4:30 PM

Date

Name of Institution

Amount

10/28/2008

Bank of America Corporation

$15,000,000,000

10/28/2008

Bank of New York Mellon Corporation

$3,000,000,000

10/28/2008

Citigroup Inc.

$25,000,000,000

10/28/2008

The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.

$10,000,000,000

10/28/2008

JPMorgan Chase & Co.

$25,000,000,000

10/28/2008

Morgan Stanley

$10,000,000,000

10/28/2008

State Street Corporation

$2,000,000,000

10/28/2008

Wells Fargo & Company

$25,000,000,000

1/ 10/28/2008

Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc.

$10,000,000,000

11/14/2008

Bank of Commerce Holdings

$17,000,000

11/14/2008

1st FS Corporation

$16,369,000

11/14/2008

UCBH Holdings, Inc.

$298,737,000

11/14/2008

Northern Trust Corporation

$1,576,000,000

11/14/2008

SunTrust Banks, Inc.

$3,500,000,000

11/14/2008

Broadway Financial Corporation

$9,000,000

11/14/2008

Washington Federal Inc.

$200,000,000

11/14/2008

BB&T Corp.

$3,133,640,000

11/14/2008

Provident Bancshares Corp.

$151,500,000

11/14/2008

Umpqua Holdings Corp.

$214,181,000

11/14/2008

Comerica Inc.

$2,250,000,000

11/14/2008

Regions Financial Corp.

$3,500,000,000

11/14/2008

Capital One Financial Corporation

$3,555,199,000

11/14/2008

First Horizon National Corporation

$866,540,000

11/14/2008

Huntington Bancshares

$1,398,071,000

11/14/2008

KeyCorp

$2,500,000,000

11/14/2008

Valley National Bancorp

$300,000,000

11/14/2008

Zions Bancorporation

$1,400,000,000

11/14/2008

Marshall & Ilsley Corporation

$1,715,000,000

11/14/2008

U.S. Bancorp

$6,599,000,000

11/14/2008

TCF Financial Corporation

$361,172,000